Struggle for survival reshapes the banking and finance sector

17 February 2009

By James Thomson - SmartCompany.com.au

The following article was produced by SmartCompany using information from D&B's commercial database.

banking&finance.jpg

The SmartCompany Dun & Bradstreet Industry Growth List for the banking and finance sector, while revealing an industry reeling from the global crisis, has also uncovered the successful fallback tactic of finding a niche and making it your own.

Australia's financial services sector is bracing for a horror year. Economic growth is slowing, sharemarkets continue to tumble and the cost of wholesale funding has gone through the roof.

Yet despite the gloom, a number of smaller companies on the SmartCompany Dun & Bradstreet Industry Growth List for the financial services sector are maintaining growth by focusing on specific niches of the sector. Specialist fund managers, data providers, research companies and finance companies continue to look for growth opportunities in a difficult market.

Compare this year's financial services industry growth list to the list from 2008 and it is easy to see the toll extracted on the sector by the global financial crisis.

The company that led last year's list, Allco Finance Group, is in the hands of receivers. Investment banking giants such as Macquarie Bank and Babcock & Brown have failed to make this year's list, and Babcock is on the brink of not surviving.

The non-bank lenders who did so well out of the property boom are gone, as are the mortgage providers. The superannuation funds that dominated last year's list are nowhere near as prominent in 2009, due to tumbling investment returns.

For all that, the growth rates recorded by this year's top 50 are impressive. Total revenue increased 33.4% from $86.9 billion to $115.9 billion in the 2007-08 financial year. The average growth rate of the companies on the list is just over 80%.

Leading the pack is investment firm Plato Investment Management, which posted revenue growth of 480% to $684,511 in the 2008 financial year.

The company, which was established in September 2006, operates five separate investment funds and has won roles managing capital for ING and Russell Investment Group.

This is one of a number of smaller companies that feature towards the top of the list, many of which have been operating for less than three years - proof of the sheer number of financial services companies that were started at the height of the economic and sharemarket boom.

Of course, those conditions are only a memory, and many of the companies are bunkering down for a difficult year. Smaller financial services sector companies are likely to find it particularly difficult this year as customers move back towards the larger - and in the case of the big banks, government-backed - players.

image1.jpg

Still searching for growth opportunities

Despite the downturn, financial services companies remain determined to find ways to grow. One such company is financial planner Snowball Group, which increased revenue by 73% to $28.5 million in the 2008 financial year.

In January the company announced two acquisitions, buying Brisbane-based groups Money Mentors and a small Adelaide planning group. Snowball managing director Tony McDonald says acquisitions have been one of the company's strengths in recent years and he is continuing to look for new targets.

Snowball concentrates on picking up small financial planning firms with well-established client bases where either the founder is getting close to retirement or the principals are looking for the support of a larger group to take the next step.

He says the downturn has helped make acquisition prices "more realistic", but says Snowball will resist the temptation to rush out on a buying spree.

"We have this absolutely unshakable belief that it's not about price at all - it's about whether people fit the family photo. By that we mean a shared belief in where the industry's going and how financial planning should be done," McDonald says.

"There is still a good demand for high-quality businesses."

The economic downturn, and particularly shocking investment returns many clients have suffered, has made life tough for financial planners and the sector's reputation has been damaged by the collapse of high-profiled financial planners like Storm Financial.

But McDonald says Snowball was very careful to manage client expectations during the bull market and managed to spot the potential downturn very early, shifting clients into cash and out of high-risk investments such as listed property trusts. More importantly, Snowball managed to resist the temptation of products such as margin loans, which have caused so much grief in the Storm situation.

"I think clients are looking more good help and there's an ocean between good help and not so good help. There's a big difference between advice that is generally holistic, strategic, customer-comes-first financial and product sales that is dressed up as advice.

"We've managed to increase our client numbers and that's the test for any financial planning group."

McDonald acknowledges that the explosive growth rates of the last few years are not likely to be repeated in the short term given the climate, but says delivering solid, consistent results for clients and shareholders is the aim.

"If I get accused of being a bit mundane at times, I accept that," he jokes.

The funding crisis

Another company bracing for more steady growth figures is listed finance company Ask Funding. The company, which focuses on lending money to people involved in personal injury legal cases, divorce cases and estate cases before their settlements come through, ranked 16th on the SmartCompany Dun & Bradstreet Industry Growth List, with revenue increasing 63% to $10.9 million in the 2008 financial year,

"In the current climate if you can firstly survive and secondly grow, then you've done very well," says managing director Russell Templeton.

The economic downturn is good for demand - if you are involved in a personal injury case that might run for two years, you are probably pretty keen to get an advance to tide you over during the recession.

But Ask Funding's resources have been stretched by the credit crunch. It has $20 million in shareholder funds and a $55 million debt facility from BankWest, but obtaining further funding from the frozen credit markets is near impossible.

"Currently we are in a position where we have more demand than we are able to meet," Templeton says.

"Our ability to grow the loan book is constrained by capital. We're working on that every month, but it's very difficult."

Templeton is extremely pessimistic about the state of the global economy and expects credit markets will remain tight well into 2010 and beyond.

In response to this, Ask Funding plans to reweight its loan book, concentrating on the relatively low-risk personal injury case funding, where payouts are contingent on government-owned workers compensation authorities, and away from divorce case funding, where payouts are contingent on household asset values, which are falling rapidly.

"We've seen cases where the value of assets involved has fallen from $4 million last year to just $1 million."

Templeton expects assets to keep falling, particularly as house prices come under pressure.

"We think it's got a long way to go - we want to be pessimistic for good reason."

The products sold by Ask Funding are relatively new in Australia and the company as invested a lot of time in educating the market, concentrating first on the lawyers who form the basis of the company's referral network.

The next step is educating the wider community Ask is about to launch a media campaign focusing particularly on its personal injury product. Templeton is currently looking for a "face" for the campaign.

"It's a tough call. If you have someone who has controversy in their life, then you wear it too."

SmartCompany Dun & Bradstreet Industry Growth List, Banking & Finance sector

Rank

Company

2008 revenue ($)

2007 revenue ($)

% change

1

Plato Investment Management

684,511

118,008

480

2

E&A

89,068,000

16,524,000

439

3

AFICO

3,563,758

783,851

355

4

CWC D&B Holdings

74,124,000

16,999,000

336

5

MQ Portfolio Management

38,189,000

11,024,000

246

6

Bendigo and Adelaide Bank

2,634,000,000

1,058,600,000

149

7

Plan Group Holdings

3,828,000

1,626,000

135

8

Mitsui & Co Financial Services (Australia)

112,724,974

52,109,183

116

9

CGU Insurance Australia

293,000,000

137,000,000

114

10

Euroz

120,739,218

63,805,598

89

11

Snowball Group

28,510,000

16,496,000

73

12

RIM Securities

557,617

327,537

70

13

Prime Financial Group

5,508,103

3,311,617

66

14

Ask Funding

10,893,518

6,702,347

63

15

Bank of Queensland

2,043,100,000

1,311,100,000

56

16

BBY

44,535,981

28,609,046

56

17

Southern Cross Equities

60,524,113

39,690,704

52

18

Equity Trustees Superannuation

6,789,975

4,454,856

52

19

Halifax Investment Services

4,321,390

2,882,096

50

20

Praemium

7,066,466

4,980,705

42

21

Trinity

49,743,000

35,193,000

41

22

Polar Finance

146,038,036

104,614,018

40

23

Newcrest Finance

1,706,100,000

1,706,100,000

39

24

Westpac Banking Corporation

25,743,000,000

18,702,000,000

38

25

Investec Holdings Australia

129,000,000

94,600,000

36

26

Komatsu Australia Corporate Finance

50,335,727

37,253,183

35

27

Investec Bank (Australia)

277,700,000

206,300,000

35

28

Members Equity Bank

132,241,000

98,388,000

34

29

CMC Markets Asia Pacific

160,546,000

120,018,748

34

30

LMI Group

2,159,528

1,615,766

34

31

Grand United Corporate Health

67,878,000

50,909,000

33

32

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group

23,634,000,000

17,809,000,000

33

33

Suncorp Life & Superannuation

224,700,000

170,600,000

32

34

Macquarie Bank

4,177,000,000

3,193,000,000

31

35

Hartleys

65,737,000

50,583,000

30

36

WHK Group

393,399,000

304,476,000

29

37

National Australia Bank

39,385,000,000

30,958,000,000

27

38

Adelaide Bank

2,101,339,000

1,656,393,000

27

39

InfoChoice

2,676,300

2,119,950

26

40

InsuranceLine

47,496,686

37,716,249

26

41

Auto & General Insurance Company

125,049,000

99,325,000

26

42

Elders Rural Bank

334,988,000

266,281,000

26

43

Insuranceline Holdings

47,632,949

37,935,380

26

44

NSW Teachers Credit Union

170,833,000

136,357,000

25

45

Nomura Australia

19,721,779

15,786,893

25

46

Suncorp-Metway

9,411,000,000

7,591,000,000

24

47

Unisuper Management

43,916,937

35,603,154

23

48

AMP Credit Union

5,223,886

4,249,219

23

49

ABN Amro Morgans

233,212,000

191,886,000

22

50

Credit Union Australia

505,493,000

416,228,000

21

Compiled by Dun & Bradstreet using information from its commercial database of more than 2.7 million companies.

 

For further information, please contact:

Danielle Woods
D&B PR Manager
02 8270 2926

About D&B

D&B is the world's leading provider of business-to-business credit, marketing and purchasing information and receivables management services. D&B manages the world's most valuable commercial database with information on more than 130 million companies.

Information is gathered in 193 countries, in 95 languages or dialects, covering 186 monetary currencies. The database is refreshed more than one million times daily as part of D&B's commitment to provide accurate, comprehensive information for its more than 150,000 customers.

The Australasian operations were bought out by the senior management group in August 2001. It was the first MBO of a wholly owned subsidiary in D&B's history worldwide.

Today Lazard Carnegie Wylie owns an approximate 90% stake in DBA and the local management team a 10% stake.

Strategies for future growth include developing DBA's commercial and consumer credit referencing business; expanding its receivables management outsourcing business; maintaining its lead in the development of unique credit and risk scoring products; and developing new products specifically tailored to the Australasian market. DBA currently employs over 500 people in Australia and New Zealand.